Friday, October 30, 2009

I Switched to 7, Should You?

This is a long post, so I'll sum things up here at the beginning. I like Windows 7 because it disappears. The new interface is intuitive, snappy, and doesn't get between me and what I want to do on the computer. I don't have to do anything tricky to get my old programs to work, and I don't have to worry about tricks to make my programs run faster. Everything just works. Period. My second major bullet point is DELL does a GREAT job of making driver installations and finding the right software easy. Just hit their website with your tag number (sticker on your Dell machine) and you have instant access to everything that came with your computer. You never have to worry about losing OS and driver discs again!

That said, keep in mind, Windows 7 is just an operating system. Computers aren't about operating systems, they're about the programs you run and ultimately, the need you meet and people you interact with.

Windows 7 is many things. To the average, minimally tech-savy user, it's intuitive and straight forward. To the business user, it's fast and lightweight (holy crap, lightweight windows!? It's true! At only 333MB of RAM, Win 7 is a major winner). To the power user, it's integrated backup, search, libraries, powerful admin tools and more. Here's what ZDNet has to say about Windows 7 vs Vista vs XP performance-wise: http://blogs.zdnet.com/BTL/?p=22006&tag=col1;post-22006

Now for my system specs and personal Windows 7 experience.
===================================

David's Machine (DELL branded 435 MT)
Use: Video editing, photo editing, gaming, work, programming, daily use
Budget media workstation, mid-range gaming PC in 2008
Value/Price Paid: $2,200/$1,200 (scratch & dent deal)
Processor: Intel Core i7-940 Nehalem, 45nm, 2.7 GHz clock, Quad core w/ Hyperthreading (8cores)
RAM: 4GB (4x 1GB) Dual channel DDR3 1333MHz
Graphics: ATI Radeon 4850 HD, PCIe 16x, 521MB GDDR 5 (b-b-b-blazing)
Disk: 1TB SATA 2 (not sure what the manufacturer is), 7200 rpm
Operating System: Windows 7 Ultimate 64-bit (Formerly Vista Home Premium 64-bit)

Internet and Quick Use PC (Asus EEE 701)
Use: Internet browsing, portable media player, hulu, vacation, note taking
Ultra-portable in 2007
Value/Price Paid: $399/$399 (yup, full price)
Processor: Intel Celeron, 65nm?, 900 MHz clock
RAM: 1.5 GB (512MB onboard + 1 GB), DDR2 667
Graphics: None
Disk: 20GB (4GB onboard SSD + 16 GB SDHC Class 6)
Operating System: Windows XP Professional N-Lite 32-bit

Family Media Center (DELL branded 531c Slim)
Use: Media library (photo/video), Light photo editing
Mid-range budget class PC in 2005
Value/Price Paid: $500/$350 (refurbished)
Processor: AMD 64 3200+, 90nm, 2.0 GHz clock
RAM: 2GB (2x 1GB) DDR2 667MHz
Graphics: None
Disk: 1TB WD Caviar Green SATA 2 (silent)
Operating System: Windows Vista Home Premium 32-bit

Guest Gaming Computer (Soltek QBIC from Scratch)
Use: Gaming when friends visit, host for data recovery
Cutting-edge gaming PC in 2004
Value/Price Paid: $900/$400 (Ray is a kickass friend)
Processor: Intel Pentium 4 Prescott, 90nm, 3.0 GHz clock
RAM: 1GB (2x 512MB) 533MHz
Graphics: ATI x1600, AGP 8x
Disk: 120 GB WD Caviar Black
Operating System: Windows XP Professional 32-bit

Now on to the good stuff!
Installation
I popped the disc into the DVD drive and restarted my computer. It booted the install disc and asked me if I wanted to upgrade, or do a custom install. I chose custom install (I always like starting fresh). I selected the partition to install on and hit the next button. Whoa! It's already installing... that's it? Aha! It tells me that another version of windows has been detected. Since I didn't want to upgrade, the old version of windows will be placed in a folder C:\windows.old. Cool, I think to myself as I hit the next button. It's off again and running. There's a message that says the machine will reboot a few times during installation. Rather than watch the pot boil, I'll go get some food and watch a quick show on my media center.

About 30 minutes into my show, the OS is installed. I plug in my serial number and create an admin account and presto, I'm on the windows desktop. It's only been 34 minutes since I started the install... could this possibly be right? Yes, it is. I'm up and ready to roll.

Ok, so now what? I'm presented with the windows 7 desktop. It doesn't look like a windows desktop. The start menu is gone and the taskbar has mac-like icons on it. Oh no!! I'm clueless and I don't know where the system tray and quick-launch tray went!? The panicky moment quickly subsides as I hover over the icons and am presented with tooltips on the new start menu and taskbar. The interface is responsive and smooth even though I haven't installed any of my drivers yet.

I opened up IE and took the windows 7 tour: http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/windows7/products/tour (Thank you microsoft.. very straightforward)

Then I went to support.dell.com and downloaded all the relevant windows 7 addons from Dell. The download and install went smoothly and all I had to do was provide the service tag number from my PC.

2 hours later and all my programs (video editing software, games, chrome, various utilities) are installed, I've checked my email, watched an hour of hulu, and... haven't restarted the computer... WHA!?!?!?

Windows 7 didn't make me reboot the computer after any of my program or driver installs. This is crazy. It's running smoothly, and I can verify the new video drivers are being used through ATI's catalyst control center.

Sweet, so now I should probably restore all of my data from the backup. I check the hard drive and find that it's still got 600GB of data on it. That can't be right, I must've, oh, wait. A quick run of TreeSize Free tells me my pics, videos, documents and everything else from my old PC is in windows.old. Awesome! I drag the folders to where they belong on the new PC. The folder relocation is almost instantaneous (no data actually got copied, the location just got updated) and I'm back where I was before the install. The system is fully functional, I've got my picasa albums and itunes library... wow. That was easy.

Interesting. The My * folders are now called libraries. This works out really well for me because I can add multiple locations. My "Family Media Center" does a file-by-file backup for recently updated data to "David's PC"\data. Now on David's PC, I can add those doc folders to the document library and have access to all my media center files for read-only access without traversing the network. Slick.

By the by, I use SyncToy 2.0 to echo my computer's files (videos, music, documents) to the media center's Data directory, and echo the media center's content to my data directory. It's handy to have a 1TB drive in each computer. SyncToy does a great job of keeping the shadow copies in sync.

I launched DDO to play with my Thursday night gaming buddies, and the windows firewall immediately prompted me to set the access level for that application. My choices are to disallow, allow internal network only, and allow internet access. I click internet (Public) and poof. That's the last time it asks and my game works like a charm.

The uber startmenu is so fast, I've decided not to install Launchy. (Essential app launcher for XP machines).

So that's that. My computer feels a little faster, and I like the snap effects for window placement. I didn't have to go in and do all the post-install tweaks I'm used to with XP and Vista. (Er, I did disable the pagefile... force of habit.)

Questions? Comments? Flaming Mac Banter? Questions/Comments on the machines I run in my network? Why do I need 4 computers?

Leave a comment and I'll get right back to you!

4 comments:

Asea said...

Hey, you forgot the Linux peeps! Flaming Linux banter for the world!

Ahem.

So this OS is smaller; do you see a noticeable difference in speed? Can you run a lot more stuff without your RAM jamming up? (Or do you have so much superRAM and computer intimidation ability that it works regardless?)

And why DO you need 4 computers, anyhow? (Not that I can really talk, seeing as I've got three and I'm not even a family...)

David said...

I feel linux advocates are an overly vocal minority. Don't get me wrong, I love my linux live CDs for data recovery and special use and enterprise systems (firewall, NAS, VOIP server, web server...), but I can't take it seriously in the consumer desktop market til it gets tools better than (not comparable to... BETTER than) the ones I currently use (Visual Studio, MS Office, Sony Vegas, iTunes, Quicktime Pro, Games games games).

After 3 days, I've noticed a major performance boost in 2 important areas, video rendering and copying files over the network, but neither of these are a testament to the smaller footprint (I'd guess it's related to the new kernel), though I can see it making a bigger difference for systems with 2GB of RAM or less.

4 computers break down to, one for me, one for Cheryl, one for watching TV (which often happens in parallel with working on a computer). The fourth is for playing multi-player games. It's handy to be able to get up and running instantly with a friend. :)

3? EEE, laptop, desktop? Why do you have 3??

Asea said...

Wellll... I got a used Thinkpad for my high school graduation, which I still technically own, but which lives in Endicott, where my brother David uses it. And then I got a used Acer piece of junk (it DOES play movies, though) in Russia to tide me over until I could get my lovely little Eee PC. Which I adore and is, for all intents and purposes, my actual computer at the moment.

Linux advocates have to be vocal, because nobody loves them. :-(

Asea said...

btw... I like this format much better. It's way easier to read.